Privy Council Clarifies Who May Conduct Litigation on Behalf of a Company in Liquidation

Manhattan Coffee Investment Holding (in liquidation) v Mwagiru [2026] UKPC 21

The Privy Council has delivered an important judgment on who may pursue litigation in the name of a company once it has entered liquidation.
The decision confirms a clear principle: where a liquidator decides not to pursue a claim, only those with a direct financial interest in the insolvency estate may ask the court for permission to continue it. Directors who are neither creditors nor contributories have no standing to do so.

Background

Before entering liquidation, Manhattan Coffee Investment Holding commenced proceedings challenging share issuances which allegedly diluted its interests in two subsidiaries. The claim was said to be worth approximately US$340 million.

Following the company’s winding up, the joint liquidators decided not to continue the litigation and instead sought to realise the company’s assets. A former director applied for permission to continue the proceedings in the company’s name, relying on the Companies Act 2001 and the Insolvency Act 2009.
The Privy Council dismissed the appeal, providing important guidance on standing, directors’ powers following liquidation and the scope of the court’s jurisdiction.

Key principles

Liquidation exists for the benefit of creditors and contributories 

The Board reaffirmed the fundamental purpose of liquidation which is to collect and realise the company’s assets and distribute them to creditors and, where there is a surplus, contributories.
That principle defines who has a legitimate interest in the conduct of the liquidation. It also determines who may seek relief where a liquidator elects not to pursue litigation.

Standing requires a direct financial interest 
The court retains jurisdiction to authorise a person other than the liquidator to conduct proceedings in the company’s name. However, that jurisdiction is narrow.

The applicant must demonstrate a direct financial interest in the outcome of the proceedings.
It is not enough to disagree with the liquidator’s commercial assessment or believe that the claim should be pursued.The judgment confirms that this threshold is generally satisfied only by creditors and contributories because they stand to benefit from any recovery.

Directors lose their powers on liquidation
The Board also clarified the position of directors following a winding up. While directors remain formally in office, their powers and functions cease unless expressly preserved by the Insolvency Act. Their status as directors does not give them authority to manage litigation or intervene in the administration of the insolvency estate.
The Privy Council endorsed the established view that directors are effectively « shorn of their powers and functions » once liquidation commences.

A right to seek directions is not a right to litigate
The appellant argued that because directors may apply to the court for directions under the Insolvency Act, they should also be entitled to seek authority to pursue litigation on behalf of the company. The Privy Council rejected that argument. A statutory right to apply for directions does not, without more, confer standing. The applicant must still establish a legitimate financial interest in the relief sought.

Not a derivative action
The judgment also draws an important distinction between a statutory derivative action and an application to conduct proceedings on behalf of a company in liquidation.
In a derivative claim, a shareholder enforces the company’s rights. In an insolvency context, the company remains the claimant; the court simply determines whether someone other than the liquidator may conduct the proceedings.

Why it matters

The decision provides welcome certainty on an issue that regularly arises where liquidators decline to pursue litigation.

It confirms that the court’s jurisdiction exists to protect the interests of the insolvency estate not those of former directors or other parties who lack an economic interest in the outcome. Standing depends on a direct financial stake in the recovery and distribution of the company’s assets. Without that interest, there is no basis for the court to authorise litigation in the company’s name.

For insolvency practitioners, the judgment reinforces the central role of the liquidator in controlling litigation and narrows the scope for challenges by parties outside the statutory scheme.

articles-loi-maurice
M. Bertrand EDOUARD BETSY, Mlle Camille ADAKEN, Mme Maëlya MAUNICK
LEGIS and Partners
articles-privy

INDEX

Legis and Partners Ltd

M. Bertrand EDOUARD BETSY

Mme Maëlya MAUNICK

Mlle Camille  ADAKEN

SHARE ON